FRESHMAN COMPOSITION, RHETORIC, GRAMMAR II

&

INTRO. TO LITERARY RESEARCH & WRITING

INSTRUCTOR: James Maxfield

Home Up Contact Instructor Instructor Bio Contents Search

Essay #4
 

bullet Illustration

English 0990 (Essay #3) and English 1010 Essay #4 (Optional Topic)

James Maxfield, Instructor

Comparison & Contrast Essay Assignment

Choose 2 of the song lyrics from the 60s that were on the handout, either 2 anti-war songs or 2 songs pertaining to social protest issues. Your major task is to compare and/or contrast how each writer presents his theme and subject within the context of the anti-war protest song genre. If you can research the meaning of the song and make a few comments about protest songs as a genre of songwriting, it will earn extra points. Only compare lyrics; not music. Researching scholarly articles in the library about your songs, the songwriters, protest songwriting, or other 60s material is not required, but will earn extra points and result in a better essay and grade. (If you need help finding an article, the library staff will be glad to assist you. Ask for help on the 4th floor of the library for help.)

Suggestions for writing your essay:

Title: Choose an appropriate catchy or provocative title that reflects your topic or thesis statement.

Introduction: Be sure to make a clear thesis statement that argues some particular point of interest or claim that you want to make. Don’t just announce your topic or intentions.

Body: First identify and summarize each song briefly noting the theme and main point of the song lyric. General information about protest songs, the 60s, or the Vietnam War can be included either in your Introduction or at the beginning of the Body section.

Then develop a well-structured discussion of at least three (3) elements of comparison or contrast, such as:

bulletsong or lyric structure
bullettype or style of narration or storytelling
bulletIs there a logical progression in the story narrative?
bulletthe writer’s use of repetition, rhetorical questions, metaphors, analogies, allusions, or other rhetorical devices, descriptive imagery, or figurative language.
bulletWhat type of narrator or main character? Protagonist? Antagonist? Reliable? Unreliable?

 

The following list can also be used as elements of comparison:

bulletlook for appeals to emotion or pity and calls for action at the end of the song or refrain
bulletcompare the writer’s choice and use of words and writing style
bulletdiscuss how Refrains or Chorus sections are used to send a message
bulletIdentify any special connotations or denotations of key words or references in the song

 

Conclusion: Summarize your main points of comparison with some final comments and restate your thesis is some fashion.

 

Send mail to james.maxfield@tri-c.edu with questions or comments about this web site.
Copyright © 2005 Cuyahoga Community College
Last modified: 04/30/06