English 1010
Instructor, James Maxfield
Notes and Suggestions on Critical Reading
The readings selected for this class have several purposes. Your paying
attention to these purposes while you are reading and making notations will
assist you in this class.
Some of the handout essays on the subject of rhetoric and style should be
read for content in order for you to become familiar with rhetorical constructs
and devices that you can use to improve your writing. The best way to study this
kind of material is to make a notebook section on rhetorical devices and figures
of speech. As you learn a new device or technique make an appropriate entry in
your book on the rule or technique with an example. As you discover new examples
of rhetorical figures and devices during your readings, copy some of these
examples into your notebook. This is an age-old practice going back to the
ancient Greeks and Romans. It was known as making a "Commonplace" notebook,
where students could record specific examples of various rhetorical tricks,
tropes, and devices to add impact to their arguments and writing.
But also note in your reading the author’s use of rhetorical modes and
structures—how the writer presents his ideas. In fact, all of the readings
should be read from that perspective: make notes for yourself how the writers
are expressing their ideas and organizing or structuring their essays. This same
advice will also apply to the short story selections. But some attention will
need to be paid to the stories themselves, especially the stories that you wish
to use for writing your term paper. If you have some idea on what subject you
wish to use for your term paper (there is a list in your syllabus under the
section on the term paper), it will help you to make notations or take specific
notes regarding that subject while you are reading. It is also suggested that
you especially note particular passages for possible quotations that you can use
in your writing. This will assist you in focusing your topic, and it will make
your paper easier to write.
I selected stories (for the most part) that are relatively short and can be
read in 30 minutes or less. I did not follow one of the suggested themes for my
choices, but rather wanted you to have a broad experience of writers from
different periods as well as from different countries.
If you are interested in writing about word choices and certain style
elements, then it might be wise for you to select only stories by native English
writers and not one of the stories in translation. But do not use this advice as
a reason for not reading those assigned stories. And be advised that paper
topics on language and style are the hardest to write at the freshman level.
Another primary purpose of the readings is to instigate your thought
processes and to generate ideas for possible essay topics. Many of our short
exercises will utilize some of our assigned readings. It is permissible and even
advisable to develop your short essays or your term paper from our class
exercises. You will not be penalized for "double-dipping."
Review Ch. 5 in our Handbook for Writers on Critical Thinking,
Reading, and Writing.